Thursday, 13 October 2016

Rant of the day: School hours



After 5 years of caring for my children (and very well I have to say), my childminder has decided to let me down. The reason? She's exhausted doing the school run. In fairness, she has kids of her own in another school and she minds 3 other kids apart from mine, so I guess she feels like she's spending more time in her car than at home.

But the real problem here is that Irish schools really make parents' life difficult.

In a way, I want to praise the Irish education system. Kids have a good routine, they go to school everyday for 5 or 6 hours, Monday to Friday. In France  there is always a big debate about school hours and days: 4 days or 4 and a half day? If it's the latter, should they have school on Wednesday morning or Saturday morning? The days are longer: 9 until 4:30pm at least in primary school, with before school and after school care within the grounds of the school. I'm sure it's tough for the kids and come Friday, they must be exhausted.

I'm not blaming the education in itself either. So far I've been very happy with my local school, the teacher who is helping my special needs son, and the curriculum. The only thing that would bother me a bit is the over-emphasis on the first communion this year as my son is doing it. But hey, I put him in a state Irish school, so I have to deal with the consequences I suppose (The consequences being the compulsory monthly mass I have to attend...).

What I'm actually fed up about is the fact that the school day ends at a different time depending what class your child is in.  I have one child in Junior infants and the other one in Second class. The youngest finishes at 1:40pm and the eldest at 2:40pm.

Seriously, what are parents or carers supposed to do during that dead hour? Stay in the car? Spend 20 mns exiting the car park, go home for 20 minutes and go back to school? And I'm not even mentioning the fortune you'd spend on petrol if you do 3 journeys to and from school everyday...

I am complaining, but the truth is, I don't even drop or collect my kids from school (bad mum I know), but I can completely understand why my childminder has given up after one month of a daily struggle.

I know the school has started to have some after school activities, but they all start at 2:40 as well, so what do I do if I want my 1:40 child to attend one of them? Well, suck it up I think and tell him he will have to wait 2 years to be able to go to the Lego club after school... That's actually the reason why my eldest didn't do any afterschool activities the first two years. The childminder couldn't have coped with the amount of travelling. By the way, did I mention the afterschool club only lasts for 45 minutes?

Anyway, I suppose this is all in the interest of the children, which is understandable, and as parents, we are supposed to put their needs and well-being before ours. But surely an over-stressed mother or childminder, going crazy because she spends most of her afternoon being a taxi driver is not going to do them any favours.

In the end, I think the Irish education system is really adapted to the needs of the children (which again is the most important thing), but they obviously didn't think about the parents.

As for us, we found a good after-school creche that will pick them up from school, supervise homework, and offer daily activities. They will even give them dinner...at 4pm, but I guess I can't have everything!!

If you're an expat parent, what do you think about your host country's education system?

Comments (6)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Most of the schools I know around my neighbourhood have an after class club/creche inhouse, and for a tiny price (around 5€ an hour in most cases) they pick up the children just outside their class, entertain them and help them for lunch, til their parents pick them up.

Probably your school could also develop such system?
1 reply · active 442 weeks ago
My school offers some after school activities, but it's only for 1st and 2nd class, it starts at 2:40pm (only for 45mns!) so my youngest cannot participate. They are looking at extending it to the youngest kids but it will take some time to implement. It's just a bit messy for school runs and I can't blame my childminder for having a nervous breakdown!!! But thankfully we have found a good afterschool who will pick them up, supervise homework and entertain them ;-)
I am surprised that your school doesn't offer "sibblings hours" that is meant for this exact purpose... It's very cheap about 10€ per week and lots of schools also have their own afterschool
Glad you've found a good creche
About French system they do 3h morning and 3h afternoon so 6h in total but they got 2h lunch break in between so 2 school runs if the kids dont stay in the "cantine"
1 reply · active 442 weeks ago
I never heard about sibling hours, it would be a great idea actually. I should talk to the school about that, I'm sure parents would be happy as well!! True for the French system, I always lived near my school so I could walk home for lunch, no school runs for my parents ;-) In saying that, Irish school should have canteens with proper meals, but that's another debate!!
I must admit I picked my son's original primary school because it had an after school club on the premises, which meant I could continue my part time job while he was in junior and senior infants, and even stay late occasionally for meeting for a small extra amount.

But I think the different finishing times is hard on older children as well as parents - is a 6-7 year old supposed to be happy sitting in the car for an hour with mum while waiting for their younger sibling to finish?
after school creches and extracurriculum clubs are so good both to parent and kids. It's a pity those, who live in smaller towns and villages have very little choice of activities, and in some cases non at all.... then parenting becomes more stressful...Hopefully it will be resolved shortly.

Post a new comment

Comments by